Claude Skill

long-command-check

Audit how an agent harness runs long shell commands, covering foreground wait limits, moving to background without re-running, timeouts, completion notification, polling, output size, cleanup and behaviour after compaction. Use when building or reviewing an agent's shell or backg

LLM Mart · 0 points · 1 views 0 listing impressions 0 install-command copies
Download minimax-ai-mcode-stack-stacks_ronny_skills_long-command-check-d520b2b.zip · 1 KB

Install

skills CLI npx skills add https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/mcode-stack/tree/main/stacks/ronny/skills/long-command-check
Claude Code claude plugin marketplace add https://llmmart.ai/marketplace.json && claude plugin install minimax-ai-mcode-stack@llmmart
Git git clone https://github.com/MiniMax-AI/mcode-stack.git

The skills CLI installs just this skill, for any of its supported agents. Claude Code installs the whole minimax-ai/mcode-stack collection as a plugin from our marketplace. Git is the plain clone.

Skill manifest

Long Command Check

For people building agents. The question is simple: when the agent runs a shell command, should it wait for it to finish? Following that question leads to a chain of design decisions. Foreground is for fast commands, background is for long ones, and ideally the same process connects the two.

Companion to MCode Engineering Notes 04, "How long should one bash command wait". Plain-text checklist: checklists/long-command.md.

Why waiting is expensive

Two costs while the agent blocks on a command:

  • The visible one: the user waits and nothing else happens.
  • The hidden one: the provider's prompt cache can expire. While a command runs in the foreground there are no new model requests. If the wait is longer than the cache lifetime of the model service you use, the next request re-processes the whole prefix: slower first token, higher cost. Look up the cache lifetime in your provider's documentation.

Moving work to the background does not keep the cache warm forever. It saves the time the agent would otherwise spend idle when it had other work to do.

How to run the audit

Read the shell tool and background-task code of the target agent. For each item, record the answer with evidence (file and function, config, or a test you ran). Do not guess; write "unknown" if the code does not show it.

# Item Question
1 Foreground limit How long does the foreground wait at most? Is that comfortably below the cache lifetime of your model service, leaving room for generation time?
2 No re-run When a command moves from foreground to background, is it the same process, or is it killed and started again?
3 Timeout accounting After moving to background and reading output, is the deadline reset? (It should not be, or a stuck command can run forever.)
4 Result delivery When a background task finishes, does the model learn it from a notification, or only by polling?
5 Notification position Is the notification appended at the end, or does it modify an already cached prefix?
6 Anti-polling Is blocking wait time capped, and does repeated reading with no change produce a hint to stop polling?
7 Output size Is large output truncated or written to a file and read incrementally, rather than pasted whole into context? Is incomplete output labelled as incomplete?
8 Cleanup Who stops background tasks when the user stops the agent, when a one-shot headless run exits, and when the process restarts? Are orphaned tasks marked instead of showing "running" forever?
9 After compaction Is "a task finished and its result was not read" tracked outside the conversation history (for example a task table), so it survives compaction?
10 Precondition If the current environment cannot read background results, is backgrounding disabled?

Quick behavioural tests

If you can run the agent, try these and record what actually happened:

  1. Ask it to start a dev server and then do something else. Does it hang?
  2. Run a command that takes several minutes. Does it move to the background without starting a second copy?
  3. Start a background task, then stop the agent. Is the task stopped?
  4. Let a background task finish, then trigger compaction before reading the result. Is the unread result still surfaced afterwards?

Output

A table of the ten items with pass / fail / unknown and evidence, the results of any behavioural tests, and the top three fixes.

Files (mcode-stack)
  • SKILL.md 3.8 KB
    ---
    name: long-command-check
    description: Audit how an agent harness runs long shell commands, covering foreground wait limits, moving to background without re-running, timeouts, completion notification, polling, output size, cleanup and behaviour after compaction. Use when building or reviewing an agent's shell or background-task tool, or when an agent hangs on dev servers, long builds or test runs.
    ---
    
    # Long Command Check
    
    For people building agents. The question is simple: when the agent runs a
    shell command, should it wait for it to finish? Following that question leads
    to a chain of design decisions. Foreground is for fast commands, background is
    for long ones, and ideally the same process connects the two.
    
    Companion to MCode Engineering Notes 04, "How long should one bash command
    wait". Plain-text checklist: `checklists/long-command.md`.
    
    ## Why waiting is expensive
    
    Two costs while the agent blocks on a command:
    
    - The visible one: the user waits and nothing else happens.
    - The hidden one: the provider's **prompt cache can expire**. While a command
      runs in the foreground there are no new model requests. If the wait is
      longer than the cache lifetime of the model service you use, the next
      request re-processes the whole prefix: slower first token, higher cost.
      Look up the cache lifetime in your provider's documentation.
    
    Moving work to the background does not keep the cache warm forever. It saves
    the time the agent would otherwise spend idle when it had other work to do.
    
    ## How to run the audit
    
    Read the shell tool and background-task code of the target agent. For each
    item, record the answer with evidence (file and function, config, or a test
    you ran). Do not guess; write "unknown" if the code does not show it.
    
    | # | Item | Question |
    | --- | --- | --- |
    | 1 | Foreground limit | How long does the foreground wait at most? Is that comfortably below the cache lifetime of your model service, leaving room for generation time? |
    | 2 | No re-run | When a command moves from foreground to background, is it the same process, or is it killed and started again? |
    | 3 | Timeout accounting | After moving to background and reading output, is the deadline reset? (It should not be, or a stuck command can run forever.) |
    | 4 | Result delivery | When a background task finishes, does the model learn it from a notification, or only by polling? |
    | 5 | Notification position | Is the notification appended at the end, or does it modify an already cached prefix? |
    | 6 | Anti-polling | Is blocking wait time capped, and does repeated reading with no change produce a hint to stop polling? |
    | 7 | Output size | Is large output truncated or written to a file and read incrementally, rather than pasted whole into context? Is incomplete output labelled as incomplete? |
    | 8 | Cleanup | Who stops background tasks when the user stops the agent, when a one-shot headless run exits, and when the process restarts? Are orphaned tasks marked instead of showing "running" forever? |
    | 9 | After compaction | Is "a task finished and its result was not read" tracked outside the conversation history (for example a task table), so it survives compaction? |
    | 10 | Precondition | If the current environment cannot read background results, is backgrounding disabled? |
    
    ## Quick behavioural tests
    
    If you can run the agent, try these and record what actually happened:
    
    1. Ask it to start a dev server and then do something else. Does it hang?
    2. Run a command that takes several minutes. Does it move to the background
       without starting a second copy?
    3. Start a background task, then stop the agent. Is the task stopped?
    4. Let a background task finish, then trigger compaction before reading the
       result. Is the unread result still surfaced afterwards?
    
    ## Output
    
    A table of the ten items with pass / fail / unknown and evidence, the results
    of any behavioural tests, and the top three fixes.
    

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet.

Reviews (0)

No reviews yet.