federal-bca
Knowledge base from OMB Circular A-94 (revised 2023-11-09) on guidelines and discount rates for benefit-cost and cost-effectiveness analysis of federal programs. Use for BCA principles, benefit/cost measurement, discount-rate policy, uncertainty/sensitivity, distributional incide
Install
npx skills add https://github.com/jgsystemsconsulting/jgs-se-knowledge-packs/tree/main/packs/federal-bca
claude plugin marketplace add https://llmmart.ai/marketplace.json && claude plugin install jgsystemsconsulting-jgs-se-knowledge-packs@llmmart
git clone https://github.com/jgsystemsconsulting/jgs-se-knowledge-packs.git
The skills CLI installs just this skill, for any of its supported agents. Claude Code installs the whole jgsystemsconsulting/jgs-se-knowledge-packs collection as a plugin from our marketplace. Git is the plain clone.
Skill manifest
OMB Circular A-94 — Federal Benefit-Cost Analysis Guidelines
Source: OMB Circular A-94, revised Nov. 9, 2023 (US Government work, public domain) | Chapters: 6
When to use
Reach for this pack when designing or reviewing federal benefit-cost or cost-effectiveness analyses—especially discount-rate selection, baseline and opportunity-cost measurement, uncertainty/sensitivity, distributional incidence, and OMB-facing documentation quality for program or legislative decisions.
Prerequisites: none — plain Markdown; no MCP server, API key, or licence tier needed at runtime.
How to Use This Skill
- Without arguments — load the core frameworks below.
- With a topic — ask about NPV, real vs nominal rates, opportunity cost, sensitivity, incidence, or CEA vs BCA.
- With a chapter — ask for
ch01throughch06.
Supporting files: glossary.md, patterns.md, cheatsheet.md.
Core Frameworks & Mental Models
Why A-94 exists
Promote social welfare via well-informed federal decisions. Provides general BCA/CEA guidance and specific discount-rate policy for time-distributed benefits and costs. Revised 2023; rescinds 1992 A-94.
Mandatory vs suggested
| Context | Force |
|---|---|
| Analyses to OMB under A-11 / A-19 / 1992 Presidential Memo estimates | Must follow |
| Internal Executive Branch planning | Suggested |
| Law / EO / other circulars prescribe methods | Those control |
Analysis spine
- Decision question + alternatives + baseline
- Identify/measure social benefits and costs (opportunity cost; transfers separated)
- Align inflation basis
- Discount with A-94 class-appropriate real/nominal rates
- Characterize uncertainty + sensitivity
- Report distributional incidence
- Document transparently for decision makers/OMB
BCA vs CEA
- BCA: Monetize benefits and costs → discounted net benefits / NPV
- CEA: When benefits fixed or not monetized → compare costs for effect (still discount correctly)
Pack scope note
Built as A-94 only after P7-PRE-2 dual-document gate: Army Cost Benefit Analysis Guide could not be retrieved (ASAFM host 403 from this environment). Do not expect Army CEAC step templates here.
Chapter Index
| # | Section | Key content |
|---|---|---|
| ch01 | Purpose, Scope, Principles | Goal, authority, mandatory use, BCA/CEA elements |
| ch02 | Benefits and Costs | Baseline, opportunity cost, inflation consistency |
| ch03 | Discount Rate Policy | Real/nominal rates, analysis classes, NPV |
| ch04 | Uncertainty | Expected values, sensitivity, explicit risk adjustments |
| ch05 | Distributional Effects | Groups, weights, economic incidence |
| ch06 | Reporting and Decision Use | OMB-grade documentation, limitations |
Topic Index
- Baseline / with-without → ch02
- BCA vs CEA → ch01, ch02
- Decision Analysis → ch04, ch06
- Discount rates (real/nominal) → ch03
- Distributional weights → ch05
- Economic incidence → ch05
- Expected value → ch04
- Inflation treatment → ch02, ch03
- Lease-purchase / asset sales rates → ch03
- Net present value (NPV) → ch03, ch06
- OMB A-11 / A-19 submissions → ch01, ch06
- Opportunity cost → ch02
- Opportunity cost / benefit identification → ch01, ch02, ch06
- Sensitivity analysis → ch04
- Social vs budget cost → ch02
- Transfers → ch02, ch05
- Uncertainty adjustments → ch04
Supporting Files
- glossary.md — BCA/discounting terms
- patterns.md — implementation patterns with When/How/Trade-offs
- cheatsheet.md — decision rules, maps, tells & smells
Scope & Limits
This pack covers OMB Circular A-94, revised November 9, 2023 (28 pages per extraction metadata) as synthesized reference notes on federal BCA/CEA guidelines and discount-rate policy.
Rescope (P7-PRE-2): Planned dual source was A-94 + US Army Cost Benefit Analysis Guide. The Army PDF was not retrievable (ASAFM 403 / Wayback 503 from the build environment). Per hard gate rules, the pack was rescoped to the surviving in-source-clean document (A-94) rather than generating Army content without evidence. Re-expand if the Army guide becomes fetchable.
It does not cover: full OMB Circular A-11 budget formulation; agency-specific statutory BCA regimes; private-sector CFA/WACC practice as a substitute for A-94; or Army CEAC process templates. US Government public domain work. No source-material download link is published.
Files (jgs-se-knowledge-packs)
-
chapters
-
ch01-purpose-scope-and-principles.md 2.9 KB
Loading… -
ch02-identifying-measuring-benefits-costs.md 2.4 KB
Loading… -
ch03-discounting-and-time.md 2.7 KB
Loading… -
ch04-uncertainty-and-sensitivity.md 2.4 KB
Loading… -
ch05-distributional-effects-and-incidence.md 2.3 KB
Loading… -
ch06-reporting-and-decision-use.md 2.3 KB
Loading…
-
-
cheatsheet.md 1.6 KB
Loading… -
glossary.md 1.7 KB
Loading… -
LICENSE 1 KB · in bundle
-
PACK.yaml 1.7 KB
Loading… -
patterns.md 1.8 KB
Loading… -
SKILL.md 5.4 KB
--- name: federal-bca description: "Knowledge base from OMB Circular A-94 (revised 2023-11-09) on guidelines and discount rates for benefit-cost and cost-effectiveness analysis of federal programs. Use for BCA principles, benefit/cost measurement, discount-rate policy, uncertainty/sensitivity, distributional incidence, and decision reporting. Rescoped at build to A-94 only (Army CBA Guide unreachable). Does not replace A-11 budget preparation detail, agency-specific statutory BCA rules, or Army CEAC process templates." --- <!-- argument-hint: [BCA, discount rate, uncertainty, incidence, CEA, or chapter number] --> # OMB Circular A-94 — Federal Benefit-Cost Analysis Guidelines **Source**: OMB Circular A-94, revised Nov. 9, 2023 (US Government work, public domain) | **Chapters**: 6 ## When to use Reach for this pack when designing or reviewing **federal benefit-cost or cost-effectiveness analyses**—especially discount-rate selection, baseline and opportunity-cost measurement, uncertainty/sensitivity, distributional incidence, and OMB-facing documentation quality for program or legislative decisions. **Prerequisites:** none — plain Markdown; no MCP server, API key, or licence tier needed at runtime. ## How to Use This Skill - **Without arguments** — load the core frameworks below. - **With a topic** — ask about NPV, real vs nominal rates, opportunity cost, sensitivity, incidence, or CEA vs BCA. - **With a chapter** — ask for `ch01` through `ch06`. Supporting files: `glossary.md`, `patterns.md`, `cheatsheet.md`. ## Core Frameworks & Mental Models ### Why A-94 exists Promote social welfare via well-informed federal decisions. Provides general BCA/CEA guidance and **specific discount-rate policy** for time-distributed benefits and costs. Revised 2023; rescinds 1992 A-94. ### Mandatory vs suggested | Context | Force | |---------|-------| | Analyses to OMB under A-11 / A-19 / 1992 Presidential Memo estimates | Must follow | | Internal Executive Branch planning | Suggested | | Law / EO / other circulars prescribe methods | Those control | ### Analysis spine 1. Decision question + alternatives + baseline 2. Identify/measure social benefits and costs (opportunity cost; transfers separated) 3. Align inflation basis 4. Discount with A-94 class-appropriate real/nominal rates 5. Characterize uncertainty + sensitivity 6. Report distributional incidence 7. Document transparently for decision makers/OMB ### BCA vs CEA - **BCA**: Monetize benefits and costs → discounted net benefits / NPV - **CEA**: When benefits fixed or not monetized → compare costs for effect (still discount correctly) ### Pack scope note Built as **A-94 only** after P7-PRE-2 dual-document gate: Army Cost Benefit Analysis Guide could not be retrieved (ASAFM host 403 from this environment). Do not expect Army CEAC step templates here. ## Chapter Index | # | Section | Key content | |---|---------|-------------| | [ch01](chapters/ch01-purpose-scope-and-principles.md) | Purpose, Scope, Principles | Goal, authority, mandatory use, BCA/CEA elements | | [ch02](chapters/ch02-identifying-measuring-benefits-costs.md) | Benefits and Costs | Baseline, opportunity cost, inflation consistency | | [ch03](chapters/ch03-discounting-and-time.md) | Discount Rate Policy | Real/nominal rates, analysis classes, NPV | | [ch04](chapters/ch04-uncertainty-and-sensitivity.md) | Uncertainty | Expected values, sensitivity, explicit risk adjustments | | [ch05](chapters/ch05-distributional-effects-and-incidence.md) | Distributional Effects | Groups, weights, economic incidence | | [ch06](chapters/ch06-reporting-and-decision-use.md) | Reporting and Decision Use | OMB-grade documentation, limitations | ## Topic Index - **Baseline / with-without** → ch02 - **BCA vs CEA** → ch01, ch02 - **Decision Analysis** → ch04, ch06 - **Discount rates (real/nominal)** → ch03 - **Distributional weights** → ch05 - **Economic incidence** → ch05 - **Expected value** → ch04 - **Inflation treatment** → ch02, ch03 - **Lease-purchase / asset sales rates** → ch03 - **Net present value (NPV)** → ch03, ch06 - **OMB A-11 / A-19 submissions** → ch01, ch06 - **Opportunity cost** → ch02 - **Opportunity cost / benefit identification** → ch01, ch02, ch06 - **Sensitivity analysis** → ch04 - **Social vs budget cost** → ch02 - **Transfers** → ch02, ch05 - **Uncertainty adjustments** → ch04 ## Supporting Files - [glossary.md](glossary.md) — BCA/discounting terms - [patterns.md](patterns.md) — implementation patterns with When/How/Trade-offs - [cheatsheet.md](cheatsheet.md) — decision rules, maps, tells & smells --- ## Scope & Limits This pack covers **OMB Circular A-94, revised November 9, 2023** (28 pages per extraction metadata) as synthesized reference notes on federal BCA/CEA guidelines and discount-rate policy. **Rescope (P7-PRE-2):** Planned dual source was A-94 + US Army Cost Benefit Analysis Guide. The Army PDF was not retrievable (ASAFM 403 / Wayback 503 from the build environment). Per hard gate rules, the pack was rescoped to the surviving in-source-clean document (A-94) rather than generating Army content without evidence. Re-expand if the Army guide becomes fetchable. It does **not** cover: full OMB Circular A-11 budget formulation; agency-specific statutory BCA regimes; private-sector CFA/WACC practice as a substitute for A-94; or Army CEAC process templates. US Government public domain work. No source-material download link is published.
Comments (0)
Sign in to join the conversation.
Reviews (0)
No reviews yet.
No comments yet.